We, Westerners, have developed something of an insatiable appetite for Japanese culture. We’ve devoured its literature, romanticised its philosophy, elevated its food into an art form and allowed its minimalist aesthetic to dictate how we furnish our homes. We’ve even adopted the Japanese philosophy of wabi-sabi, seemingly forgetting that finding beauty in imperfection is a considerably more complicated exercise than buying an asymmetrical ceramic vase.
Yet, for all our enthusiasm for Japanese cultural sensibilities, one particularly significant element remains conspicuously absent from our collective obsession: jazz.
Of course, Britain has its jazz aficionados, its fiercely dedicated musicians and an independent scene that has produced some of the most inventive contemporary ensembles in the world. But why has jazz struggled to inspire the same widespread cultural affection that we readily extend to Japanese literature, architecture and design?
Considering our national obsession with being perceived as culturally discerning, you’d think we’d be falling over ourselves to embrace the soundtrack of the original hipsters.
Instead, somewhere between the vinyl revival and our collective infatuation with Haruki Murakami, we appear to have forgotten to listen to the records.
We Love Murakami’s Existentialism, but What About His Record Collection?
It seems almost impossible to discuss Japan’s contemporary literary identity without mentioning Haruki Murakami. His novels have become something of a cultural passport for readers eager to inhabit worlds where emotional alienation, surrealism and existential uncertainty exist within the strange theatre of everyday life.
But Murakami’s relationship with jazz deserves far more attention than the occasional reference to a record spinning in the background of his fiction.
Before establishing himself as a novelist, Murakami opened Peter Cat, a jazz café in Tokyo, in 1974. Music subsequently became inseparable from his literary identity, influencing the rhythm and sensibility of his prose.
Jazz provided an artistic vocabulary for his exploration of loneliness and the psychological absurdities of modern existence. Its improvisational nature seems particularly suited to fictional worlds where characters stumble through emotional uncertainty without the reassurance of a conventional resolution.
There’s a certain irony in Western readers celebrating the existential atmosphere of Murakami’s fiction while remaining relatively indifferent to the music that helped inform it.
We understand why a character might spend several pages contemplating an ordinary object as though it contains the secrets of existence, yet apparently draw the line at an extended saxophone improvisation.
Perhaps the problem is that literature allows us to experience existential uncertainty at a comfortable distance. Jazz demands something more immediate, requiring us to confront ambiguity without a narrator explaining what we’re supposed to feel.
And perhaps that’s precisely what makes it worth hearing.
Japan Understood That Listening Could Be a Cultural Act
Japan’s relationship with jazz extends considerably further than Murakami’s personal record collection.
Jazz was born from African American musical innovation, its evolution inseparable from the social realities and artistic resistance of Black American communities. Its arrival in Japan eventually inspired a distinctive listening culture that treated recorded music as something deserving sustained attention.
During the post-war decades, jazz kissaten, or jazz cafés, became important cultural spaces where enthusiasts gathered to hear records through high-quality sound systems.
These establishments were particularly significant when imported recordings were prohibitively expensive and access to music was considerably more restricted than it is today. Some also became associated with student activism and countercultural intellectual life.
The concept sounds almost radical by contemporary standards: people would enter an establishment with the specific intention of listening to recorded music in a relaxed setting.
Imagine that.
There was no obligation to document the experience for social media, no algorithm suggesting something more palatable after thirty seconds, and certainly no need to apologise because a composition refused to arrive at its chorus quickly enough.
Naturally, romanticising Japanese listening culture as some universally enlightened relationship with music would be ridiculous. Japan has its mainstream pop industry and disposable entertainment, while historically, certain jazz cafés could be intimidating, intensely male-dominated spaces.
Nevertheless, there’s something compelling about a culture that created dedicated environments for music to be appreciated beyond its usefulness as social accompaniment.
Western interpretations of Japanese minimalism frequently reduce the philosophy to aesthetics, stripping away the underlying relationship between attention, intention and experience.
Perhaps we’ve made a similar mistake with jazz.
We’ve become exceptionally good at admiring the paraphernalia of musical appreciation, from expensive turntables to carefully curated record collections, while becoming increasingly impatient with the act itself.
You can apparently purchase the appearance of having excellent taste considerably more easily than you can develop it.
The Original Hipsters Had Better Record Collections
There’s another contradiction within our cultural reluctance towards jazz: the very concept of being hip has deep historical associations with the genre.
Long before the contemporary hipster became identifiable through vintage clothing and an almost religious commitment to independent coffee shops, the language of hipness circulated through jazz communities.
The hepcats of the 1930s and subsequent jazz enthusiasts helped establish an understanding of cool rooted in musical knowledge and cultural awareness.
Jazz was a language of artistic rebellion, refusing to surrender individual expression to convention.
It was sophisticated without requiring permission from established cultural authorities. Its musicians challenged harmonic expectations and transformed improvisation into an unapologetic declaration of individuality.
Somewhere along the line, contemporary hipster culture inherited the appetite for distinction while apparently misplacing much of the musical adventurousness that made the original movement interesting.
We celebrate obscure post-punk records, seek out the strangest experimental electronica and enthusiastically champion artists who seem determined to dismantle conventional songwriting.
Yet mention jazz and a surprising number of otherwise adventurous listeners seem to imagine a technically impressive but emotionally impenetrable exercise in musical self-indulgence.
The stereotype has become almost comically resistant to revision.
Jazz is supposedly the preserve of ageing men discussing chord progressions, intellectually intimidating audiences and musicians who play seventeen notes where three would supposedly suffice.
Which rather overlooks the fact that jazz has spent much of its existence dismantling precisely those expectations.
Anyone who can appreciate the hypnotic repetition of post-punk, the textural dissolution of shoegaze or the disorientating structures of experimental rock already possesses an appetite for some of jazz’s most mesmeric characteristics.
The genres may approach emotional expression differently, but they share an interest in what happens when familiar musical structures become unstable.
For listeners who claim to crave originality, jazz should be considerably more tempting than its reputation suggests.
Britain Has the Musicians. So Why Does Jazz Still Feel Like a Specialist Interest?
It’s important to recognise that Britain isn’t suffering from a shortage of exceptional jazz musicians.
If anything, the contemporary UK scene provides a rather damning rebuttal to anyone insisting that jazz belongs in a museum.
Take Portico Quartet, for example, whose hypnotic synthesis of jazz, ambient textures and electronica possesses an almost architectural relationship with sound. Their Mercury-nominated debut, Knee Deep in the North Sea, demonstrated how effortlessly jazz could inhabit the same artistic territory as experimental alternative music.
Or consider Ezra Collective, whose historic 2023 Mercury Prize victory made them the first jazz act to claim the award. Their success challenged the notion that jazz was destined to remain an ornamental addition to Britain’s musical landscape.
Then there’s the work of Nubya Garcia, Yussef Dayes and Moses Boyd, artists who have contributed to a British jazz culture informed by the communities and musical histories surrounding them.
Their existence makes the familiar assertion that jazz is inaccessible increasingly difficult to defend.
Yet despite these breakthroughs, jazz still seems to suffer from an image problem in wider popular culture.
Part of that problem may lie in how music is marketed.
Contemporary discovery culture is obsessed with defining records through instantly recognisable emotional categories. Music becomes something to accompany studying, exercising or romanticising your commute, preferably without demanding too much attention.
Jazz is frequently relegated to the background, reduced to an agreeable atmosphere rather than recognised as an artistic experience capable of provoking the same emotional extremes as any revered alternative rock album.
We’ve inherited the idea that jazz is serious music, something to be respected from a polite distance. The implication is that enjoying it requires an understanding of music theory or an encyclopaedic knowledge of its historical movements.
That attitude is particularly absurd when you consider how much of jazz’s history is rooted in physical expression, spontaneity and social participation.
Fortunately, the growing popularity of Japanese-inspired listening bars in Britain suggests that our relationship with recorded music may be shifting. Venues such as London’s Spiritland have helped bring attentive listening into a contemporary social setting But there’s still an uncomfortable question hanging over this fashionable revival.
Are we learning to appreciate music differently, or have we simply discovered another aesthetically pleasing environment in which to consume expensive drinks?
Buying into the appearance of musical sophistication is easy. Giving an unfamiliar recording your undivided attention requires considerably more curiosity.
Conclusion: Perhaps Being Hip Means Learning to Listen Again
I don’t believe Britain needs to become Japan, nor should we pretend that Japanese jazz culture represents some flawless artistic utopia.
The problem is considerably closer to home.
We have become too comfortable celebrating cultural adventurousness as an identity while displaying surprisingly little patience for the unfamiliar experiences that might actually justify it.
Jazz seems particularly vulnerable to this contradiction because it refuses to present itself as an easily digestible cultural product.
It can be abrasive, seductively melancholic, confrontational or so rhythmically infectious that any accusations of intellectual pretension become laughable.
It also happens to possess one of the richest histories of musical resistance and artistic experimentation imaginable.
So perhaps the next time we’re tempted to buy another Japanese-inspired objet d’art, we could consider engaging with something a little less decorative.
Find a jazz record. Give it the same attention you’d offer a Murakami novel. Let the music take you somewhere unexpected without demanding that it immediately justify the destination.
And if you’re still determined to cultivate the persona of a culturally discerning hipster, you might as well take a little inspiration from the people who made being hip interesting in the first place.
They had better taste in music, anyway.
Written by Amelia Vandergast
